Skip to primary navigationSkip to main contentSkip to footer
  • Start a Custom Project
  • Call Us
  • Locations
  • Call UsToggle Call Us Menu
    • Appleton
    • Oshkosk
  • Visit UsToggle Visit Us Menu
    • Appleton
    • Oshkosh
Tennies Jewelry logo
  • Custom
    • Learn About Our Process
    • Hierloom & Redesign
    • Our Custom Gallery
  • Bridal
    • Engagement Rings
    • Women's Wedding Bands
    • Men's Wedding Bands
  • Diamond Jewelry
    • Studs
    • Tennis Bracelets
    • Earrings
    • Necklaces & Pendants
    • Rings
    • Bracelets
  • Gemstone Jewelry
    • Shop by Birthstone
    • Earrings
    • Necklaces & Pendants
    • Rings
    • Bracelets
    • Pearls
  • Fashion Jewelry
    • Earrings
    • Necklaces & Pendants
    • Rings
    • Bracelets
  • Chains
  • Charms
  • Designers
    • Berco
    • Levy Creations
    • Luvente
    • Nicole Barr
    • Parle
    • Rembrandt Charms
    • Romance Bridal Collection
    • Royal Chain
    • S. Kashi & Sons
    • Unique Settings
  • Services & Repairs
    • Chain Repair
    • Cleaning & Inspection
    • Custom Jewelry
    • Hierloom & Redesign
    • Financing Options
    • Jewelry Appraisals
    • Jewelry Insurance
    • Jewelry Repairs
    • Pearl & Bead Restringing
    • Rhodium Plating
    • Ring Resizing
    • Tip & Prong Repair
    • Watch Batteries
  • Pay Over Time
    • Revolving Credit
    • Tennie's Layaway
  • About Tennie's
    • Our History
    • Our Staff
    • Store Events
    • Make an Appointments
  • Start a Custom Project
  • Call Us
  • Locations
Log In My Cart (0)
Tennies Jewelry logo
  • Toggle Search Menu
  • Toggle My Account Menu
  • Toggle My Wishlist
  • Toggle Shopping Cart Menu
Jewelry Insurance Your jewelry is more than just metal and stones — it’s a symbol of love, milestones, and memories. That’s why we proudly offer two trusted insurance partners to help you protect your most meaningful pieces: BriteCo and Jewelers Mutual. Tennies Jewelry Appleton, WI

Jewelry Insurance

Your jewelry is more than just metal and stones — it’s a symbol of love, milestones, and memories. That’s why we proudly offer two trusted insurance partners to help you protect your most meaningful pieces: BriteCo and Jewelers Mutual.

BriteCo™Jewelers Mutual

Why Insure Your Jewelry?

Loss, theft, damage, or even a missing stone — life happens. Insuring your jewelry gives you peace of mind knowing that your treasured items are protected, no matter what. Whether it’s your engagement ring, heirloom bracelet, or everyday earrings, coverage ensures you can repair or replace them without stress or out-of-pocket surprises.
Tennies Jewelry Appleton, WI

BriteCo™

Fast, modern, and built for today’s jewelry owners.

BriteCo offers instant quotes, online enrollment, and coverage up to 125% of your jewelry’s value. Their policies include loss, theft, damage, and mysterious disappearance — all with no deductible. Coverage can begin immediately after appraisal, and claims are handled quickly and digitally.

Learn More
Tennies Jewelry Appleton, WI

Jewelers Mutual

A legacy name in jewelry insurance trusted for over 100 years.

Jewelers Mutual offers comprehensive coverage for engagement rings, wedding bands, watches, and more. Their flexible policies protect against loss, theft, damage, and disappearance, with personalized service and repair work done right here at Tennie’s Jewelry.

Read More
Tennies Jewelry Appleton, WI

Ready to Get Covered?

Stop in for an appraisal, or let us walk you through your coverage options in-store. We’re happy to answer any questions and help you choose the right insurance plan for your needs.

Visit UsSend Us a Message
Appleton Hours
Mon - Fri:10:00am - 6:00pm
Saturday:10:00am - 2:00pm
Sunday:Closed
Appleton Address
208 East College Ave
Appleton, WI 54911
(920) 734-1858
Store Information
Osh Kosh Hours
Monday:Closed
Tues - Fri:10:00am - 6:00pm
Saturday:10:00am - 2:00pm
Sunday:Closed
Oshkosh Address
523 N. Main St
Oshkosh, WI 54901
(920) 231-0462
Store Information
Our Jewelry
  • Engagement Rings
  • Wedding Bands
  • Earrings
  • Necklaces and Pendants
  • Chains
  • Rings
  • Bracelets
  • Charms
Socials
Our Services
  • Chain Repair
  • Cleaning & Inspection
  • Custom Jewelry
  • Financing
  • Gold & Diamond Buying
  • Jewelry Appraisals
  • Jewelry Repairs
  • Pearl & Bead Restringing
  • Rhodium Plating
  • Ring Resizing
  • Tip & Prong Repair
  • Watch Batteries
Store Menu
  • About Tennie's
  • Jewelry Education
  • Our Reviews
  • Social Media
  • Create an Account
Become a Member

Join for free and discover exclusive access to our biggest drops, promotions, members-only products, and more.

Join Now for Free

© 2025 Tennies Jewelry. All Rights Reserved. Website designed, maintained, and hosted by  Punchmark.

  • Return Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Accessibility Statement

Learn how we use cookies in our Privacy Policy or manage cookie preferences.